|
Sociology: Cultural
Emotion
Winter Quarter 2009 |
A
Politics and Emotion:
Berezin. some examples of what you could
"pull" from the chapter
ALL - not just those in group; all can participate. |
| 1 |
one individual in
an emotional zone is not necessarily codifying,
managing, mobilizing the emotion. p 35.
if s/he is codifying, managing, mobilizing the
emotion, then she transforms emo into culturally
acceptable behaviors. The function of emo -
when personal is political. The micro
as political. example:
fight prone - balance within - harmony without -
better at work, better for all. |
| 2 |
Aristotle
has a list of 10 emotions page 37: have some
abstract fun with them. How diagram his 10 in
terms of social relationship of power, loss (fear)
v. love, male - female or other social variable |
| 3 |
secure state
- can become an insecure state. Influx of
immigrants. melting pot to stark to starker
immigration in the US: jobs, language
immigration in Europe: jobs, language,
clothes, law (women) |
| 4 |
communities of
feeling - see pages 39-40. See the story about
"buy war bonds" as an example of how a group can
feel something 9/11, B.O., Burning Man,
Super Bowl, A Song, an act of nature, a winner (all
the winner programs and movies), revenge, duty,
pride, shame. |
| 5 |
page 40-42.
on embedding emo in political institutions.
there are emo bonds and feelings of national
unity. Propinquity has a lot to do
with it - immigration - Barack Obama -
consciousness |
| 6 |
p 45.
Ritual eliminates indeterminacy in social space.
Public political ritual creates an open
interpretive space. Show this. |
| 7 |
p. 46 the more
fragile the group solidarity, the more likely
the group is to respond with violence.
|
| 8 |
p. 47-48 There is a
commitment to the familiar and a fear
of instability. Threats to group security.
Security
allows generosity. |
| 9 |
p. 48 in a secure
state, we can define what we have a "right to
expect"
in a secure state, we have a national
community of feeling |
| 10 |
p. 49
institutions of state can collapse as they
did in Eastern European countries: in what
historical story do you life, e.g., Armenian
immigrants - sharing the story?
This means any story - narrative - of
sociological and spiritual awakening, for the
personal is the political. |
A "politics"
- interest in when
collective emotion becomes action - or dissipates?
historical revolutions or rebellions or riots?
action in the street? action in any context.
"social currents" (Durkheim)
NEW ONE:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123336391229335459.html
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=2&recnum=1&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A2%3A0%2C0%2C2
Culture in Action by Ann Swidler, sociologist,
1986. Need NIS account.
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=10&recnum=2&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A10%3A80%2C0%2C10
primitive
revolt in Paris, 2005 Need NIS account.
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=33&recnum=4&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A33%3A240%2C0%2C10
<-- affective
intelligence and political judgment (2007)
|
B Crisis or Exuberance
Kemper -
some examples of what you could "pull" from the
chapter. ALL - not just those in group; all
can participate. |
|
1
there are individual
emotions and group emotions. Individuals have
different positions vis-a-vis a group emotion |
Any group fear or group
joy is marked by different emotional responses among
the participants. Kemper calls it a "division of
labor." This would hold from everything from
"revolution" or "riot" and social class to a
burglary and how the man responds vs. how the woman
responds to political joy and the variation in
emotion between supporters and detractors |
|
2 all
theories have to predict; therefore a theory of
emotions has to predict either when emotions arise
or when collective emotions give rise to action |
do all theories have to
predict? some are classificatory. |
|
3 p 54 55
the distinction between
power and status |
emotional difference
when sometimes we have to do things because we feel
or are forced (power by someone else to assert his
will) and other times we do things because we accord
one another status. |
| 4
p. 56 what comes
from what |
anger
from loss of status
fear from loss of power
sadness from irremediable loss of status
joy from gain of status
guilt from use of too much power
shame when act in manner belying status |
| 5
57-59 who felt
what at 9/11 in NY |
p 66 -
present the table for discussion |
| 6
joy, jubilation,
victory |
what
group emotion sample do you have where a group felt
joy? what "division of labor" did various
people have around the joy? what social action
came from the joy or did it just dissipate?
You could even take something like the Super Bowl
and include all parties including people stuck in
the kitchen, if any, people who bet and who didn't,
people who were for the Cardinals, people who didn't
care if they were there. Or take the election
of the President - and a group. |
| 7 59 -
62 what is the
benefit of predicting emotions and/or dealing with
emotions? |
You
could use some journal experience for this one |
| 8
p 62-63
leadership and legitimacy. |
"Representatives cannot indifferently conclude
agreements that defy their group's prevailing
sentiments without courting a legitimacy crisis.this
would be a good place to discuss the economic crisis
and emotion and the new economic stimulus proposal |
| 9
emotion and
crisis in interpersonal networks and extended
families |
find a
reference in 1-2 of the sections above in this Topic
B to help illuminate a group vulnerability in a
group you know. describe the group emotion and
the division of labor of individuals around that
emotion |
| 10
money and
emotion |
different forms of sharing; the extended family and
financial support (caring for children, caring for
elderly, pitching in), forms of cutbacks people
recently did - do a survey; tell stories; draw the
picture |
B "crisis"
or "solution" - interest in individual or collective emotion
from crisis or answer (e.g., Obama)
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=20&recnum=3&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A20%3A178%2C0%2C10
<-- emotion and gender and Israeli condition today (2006)
Need NIS account.
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=23&recnum=7&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A23%3A195%2C0%2C10
<-- emotions in SE Asia: violence against gays
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=26&recnum=1&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A26%3A208%2C0%2C10
<-- Evangelical Christians and "Collective" emotions
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=33&recnum=9&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A33%3A240%2C0%2C10
<-- public fears and urban terrorism
C "economics"
- interest in money and emotion - collective or individual
(current situation pertinent!)http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=23&recnum=8&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A23%3A195%2C0%2C10
<-- emotions in Thailand in economic crisis
|
D Work Chart
work and emotions (make a beautiful graphic -
abstract, not newspaper cut outs) - divide up your
own chapter |
|
1
professionals |
hide
emotion; top professional can show emotion of a -
(negative) sort. Not show emotion of a + sort.
Even "shirt sleeves" in the Oval office |
|
2.
professionals who "deal with"
emotions |
shrinks;
counselors, cops, service personnel, priests; all
the "new age helpers", anger management, etc. |
|
3
laws about emotion |
all
criminal law: about invasion (looming)
all contract & tort law: can
re-adjust (rational) |
|
4
service workers - robot extenders |
bling
(Jennifer A). When an extension of a computer
either
A. plastered on smile (or smiling phone voice)
B. plastered on serious, important
A tends to deal w public more - but B serious even
with publice |
| 5
actors, singers, sports stars,
criminals & crooks, fanatics: create emotion |
sports: create
a complex of emo: Now, Team (anti-other team),
and history Actors do it for
the NOW (less history, less 'team')
FANatics |
| 6
which professions are
emotion-free |
any? |
| 7 |
YOU |
| 8
|
DIVIDE |
| 9
|
THE |
| 10
|
CHAPTER |
D "work" - which jobs are
"about" emotions? (counseling, etc.), which jobs
require control of emotion (ER, prison guard, etc.), which
jobs create emotions (actors, sports, etc.), which emotions
come out where on the power structure at work, how are
emotions regulated (sexual harassment, training, etc.)
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=26&recnum=1&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A26%3A208%2C0%2C10
<-- humor and the workplace (as relief!)
|
E
Thought what are you TOLD is true?
what do you KNOW is true? 2 chapters:
Bloch and Barbalet |
|
1 p 114
Bourdieu: every scientific
'choice' is a political investment strategy,
directed, objectively at least, toward maximization
of strictly scientific profit |
have you
ever felt you could detect a professor's political
preferences in class, passing as social science or
humanities? |
|
2 p 115
peer review seen anthropologically is
seen as an exchange of gifts. paradox: science
as a vlue and desire for recognition |
the
researcher presents his or her results to the
scientific community and where, on the BASIS of the
logic of gift-giving, acceptance of the gift implies
a recognition of the status of the giver - (giver is
a valued researcher). |
|
3
p 113 competition and recognition
p 115 peer judged |
the social relations of rationality |
|
4
p. 117 - FOR A few pages the empirical study of
emotions and science. 54 respondents
maybe 3 people on this topic #4 |
report on it
P120-121: the deceiving game
pm 121-122: tact
P 125-6 shame, anger, broken social
bonds |
|
5
Barbalet chapter |
radical separation of science and
emotion: abolish eloquence in language!
page 133 |
|
6
Barbalet chapter p 134,5,6 |
science as activity, with value-free
"tone" |
|
7
p 137 emotion of an era |
every era has a way of thinking and
being |
|
8
p 137-138 alchemy, astrology, magic |
why are these not sciences? why
are people emotional about them |
|
9
p 138-9 science as
organization |
work as an individual; judged as a
group
Wonder Vs. Utility
Take "global warming" - science mixes
with emotion |
|
10
the greats |
how do these "big thinkers" think
about emotion and science
Merton 136
Aristotle 138
Bacon 138
Newton 138
Sartre 142
Adam Smith 142
143 Albert Einstein |
| 11 Classicism -
Romanticism |
Rep
Dem
Man
Woman
Science
Art
Reason
Magic |
| |
|
E "thought"
- science vs. religion, emotion vs. logic, Democrats vs.
Republicans or "left" v. "right", language itself
http://csaweb102v.csa.com.mimas.calstatela.edu/ids70/view_record.php?id=30&recnum=0&log=from_res&SID=773ugqmhs01ubj0u8v3npkfkj0&mark_id=search%3A30%3A235%2C0%2C2
<-- sociology as art! emotion+rationality
emotion+scientific thought
|
|
|
|
|

|